Which is better, Babysitters Club or the Boxcar Children?

Which is better, Babysitters Club or the Boxcar Children? [initials redacted]
Which is better, Babysitters Club or the Boxcar Children? [initials redacted]

Both definitely evoke childhood nostalgia, though your birth year might impact which series feels the most nostalgic for you. The first Boxcar Children mystery came out in the 1920s and new books are still being published, while the Babysitters Club books are a reflection of the 1980s and 90s when they were written. Both are still wildly popular, inspiring TV and graphic novel adaptations, so I’d call it a tie.